DD. J. Smith
22 de enero de 2023
Excellent value, works well with Google
I've installed more than 50 of these smart switches across several properties.Price-wise, these are on par with Lutron "dumb" switches that you'd buy at a big box store, and you get much more functionality.Installation is straightforward for anyone familiar with basic electrical work. It's a bit like a GFCI outlet, though- they are fairly bulky, so there's not going to be a lot of spare room in the box. It can be tricky to get two of these into a duplex box. (Waygo's, or very, very neat wiring are your friend)We use these with Google Home, and they work very well. The only complaint I have about the integration is setting them up twice- once in the Kasa app, and then again in Google Home. It would be great if the setup process were all in one place and just flowed through. For example, when i have "Living Room" in both apps, Google Home should realize that I've set up a switch in Kasa and automatically assign it to "Living Room" in Google. I realize that is on Google- it's just something that should be addressed.Once it is integrated, though, you can mimic a much more expensive home automation system. I've seen homes with $30k-$50K just on home automation. These switches do a darn good job of mirroring that, and they don't require a server to run them. We've set up "scenes" like "Hey Google, it's time for movies"- and then Google can address the various switches and dim the lights, close the blinds, etc. It's quite a luxurious feeling.What I particularly like about these switches is that they stay connected to our wifi pretty well. I've experimented with several other brands, and some of them will drop off the wifi on an annoyingly frequent basis. I want to install, then not think about it again. In my primary residence, we have >30 switched that have been running for about a year. Only one has ever needed to be reconnected to wifi, and that has only happened once so far. (btw, reconnecting is relatively easy, as there are reset buttons carefully hidden on the front of the device- you don't have to take it out of the wall).So all in, electronics are well designed, installation is about what you'd expect, and integration with Google Home is pretty good. Kasa has done a very nice job with these switches.
DDerek O.
11 de diciembre de 2024
These are affordable and life changing!
I am just going to come out and say it. We freakin love these things. over the last 4+ years of owning our home we have swapped out almost every single light switch in our house with these Kasa Switches.Models we have:Kasa Smart Light Switch HS200P3 - Your standard light switchKasa Smart Dimmer Switch KS220P3 - This is your standard dimmer switchKasa Smart 3 Way Switch HS210 - 3 way switchWe are a Google family with the exception of our 12 year old daughter how has yet to see the light but we are working on it. These switches are all hooked up to Google Home so we can either get off the couch and flick the switch like an animal or we can simply say: Hey Google, Turn off the kitchen lights. we have everything grouped in Google Home by room and function of the switch which make it a breeze for even my kids to use. My wife is British and to be fair she does struggle with it understanding her from time to time but I do not encounter that problem so I am giving these bad boys 5 stars. They are a modern bright white that matches our home, the install was so easy that even a colorblind adult (me) could do it, initial setup is very easy but if you do change your wifi name and network details you will need to reconfigure them which can be a bit of a pain in the buttocks. We have only had to do this once and I do not recommend it. We like these so much we have even purchased them as a house warming gift for my ungrateful brother and he is also now hooked on the smart tech they offer. I recommend these and will certainly be buying more in the future.
Love it. Works good
Love it. Now my light switch is smart and I can control my lights with the Alexa and app. No more having to get up when forgetting to turn off the lights. Easy to wire up and connect. App is good and you cam fine tune the lights and even have them on a schedule too so they can automatically turn on/off at times of the day. The switch was compatible with all my led lights around the house after adjusting the high and low dim
Great switch, needs more smart actions
I installed 25 tp-link switches (combination of dimmer, switch, and 3 way switch) in my home, and one wemo dimmer.Installation: The tp-link dimmers and switches have different attachment hardware (where you screw the switch to attach it to the electric box in the wall). This is annoying because the switches have a thick plastic, while the dimmers are metal but have a piece of plastic that screws onto the top of the front which has to be removed. I personally prefer the dimmer metal hardware. When you install a dimmer next to a switch you have to really fiddle with them to make the two different sizes look the same after the cover is on.What I like:I really like the fact that I can control these from the switch, my phone, or the from google assistant.I also have a in wall wemo dimmer. When I tell google to turn off or on the lights the wemo is significantly slower to respond then the tp-link. For tp-link the lights start to turn on//off in probably .5 sec while the wemo dimmer may take 2-8 seconds to start to respond.Look - the switches and the covers have a bright shiny finish. In most cases I was not able to use the included cover as they are installed in double or triple switch settings, but I like them where I was able to use them.Light compatibility - I've installed these with multiple kinds of dimmable LED lights and they have all functioned well.Light range - I replaced my living room light which originally had the wemo dimmer switch and I noticed that the tp-link uses a greater range of the light bulb - i.e. it dims more and 100% brightness is brigher which I like.These also pretty quickly reconnect to wifi after I flip the breaker off or power outage (unlike some of my other smart devices that I have to setup over an over again with every power blip)Enhancements I would really like:Enabling third party triggers. I use IFTTT to integrate multiple smart things together. While these dimmers are compatible with IFTTT - they are only able to be used as THAT devices (in the "if this than that"(ifttt) recipes). So for example, with my wemo switch, if I wanted to turn on/off some other smart device when I clicked the wemo dimmer switch, I could use the wemo click as a THIS action or trigger. But these switches I can only use to respond to other actions, for example, when my door sensor senses that the door opened I can turn on the entry way light.True Instant on/off: The dimmer switches have a setting where you can change how fast they dim on and off when you click the switch. One option is "Instant". When I have it set to instant, it really just dims on/off fast. I have a non dimmer switch right next to a dimmer switch and when I click both at the same time the dimmer light takes longer, probably a second to turn on, while the non-dimmable switch is instant. This would also probably help with non-dimmable lights. I had non-dimmable lights attached to some of my dimmers and these acted very poorly even when set to instant on. They really buzzed and some even continued to buzz loudly while on.Always on circle light in switch - In places where I have three dimmers together, when I turn one light on, that switches circle on the switch turns off. When I go to turn the light off I instantly think that the switches with the light on are the ones that are on, so I click those two only to find that neither of those lights were on and end up cycling through all three switches.In the kasa app when you select a dimmer or a switch the UI is completely different, it would be nice for them to be more similar.What I don't like -The click. About 1 out of every 4 times that I click the switch it doesn't turn on/off. Probably similar to learning to double click on a computer mouse for the first time (for those that can remember that). This could also probably be resolved with the instant on/off I mentioned before. Because it takes about a second even on instant on for the light to come to full power, when you click on and didn't click hard enough you end up walking past the switch thinking it is just takings its second to dim on, but then you have to walk back to the switch once it actually doesn't work. Some of my switches also have a bit of a squeaky click, which is also annoying.Note about 3-way switches - Even though my house was built fairly recently, for every set of three way switches, only one of the two wall wirings has the white wire. Luckily these can be paired with an old dumb three way switch and work quite well (i.e. you can use a single 2 pack of 3-way switches for two separate sets of 3-way sockets)Note about wifi - I have mesh wifi in a smallish house so my wifi coverage is good throughout and wifi connectivity has not been an issue for switches.Update Feb 2020:Smart actions - Auto off action. I really like this feature. I have my bathroom vent fans set to auto off after 15 minutes, and I think it has always worked except for one time my WiFi was down. The problem, your only allowed 3 smart actions. I’d love to be able to set more. My son uses the bathroom at the far end of my house and leaves the light on every time. A 15 minute auto off would be perfect. It would also work for closet and hallway lights. TP-link please add more smart actions.